In terms of live action television, those based off of a comic book have never seen much mainstream success.
Shows such as Adam West’s
Batman, The Incredible Hulk, and the more recent
Smallville are often remem
bered more for their
camp value than their quality storytelling.
That’s not to say that these shows did not have their high points (
Smallville’s Clark Kent/Lex Luthor frenemy relationship comes to mind. For proof of that here's a
creepy fan music video), just that for the most part these shows failed to fully capture the heart and imagination of the characters and story in which they were based upon.
That’s why it feels so surprising that The Walking Dead has turned out so damn good. Week after week, the show succeeds in leaving me hanging on the edge of my seat with anticipation. It makes sense though. On paper, the show has all the right ingredients for success; a (mostly) likeable cast, characters that are very much three-dimensional, gratuitous blood and gore, and perhaps the only monsters that could rival Edward Cullen in popularity; zombies.
While a comic book show succeeding so well in and of itself is unexpected, it’s only fitting that it happens with one based off of a post-apocalyptic, zombie-filled world.
For whatever reasons, zombies have gotten their cold, clammy hands on virtually every form of popular culture, it’s only natural that they would creep their way over to ongoing television.
The show is based off of what was originally somewhat of a
cult-classic comic book of the same name, and the comic is still going strong to this day, growing ever closer to that elusive issue #100.
Robert Kirkman, creator of the series, has helmed the series since the very first issue, and has been very
hands on with the show since the beginning, trying to stay true to the spirit of the comic.
The spirit of the comic that is, not the storyline. In terms of storytelling, the show jumps back and forth between staying true to the original comic’s storyline and veering off into completely different directions. Without a doubt, this is my favorite aspect of the show. On one hand, it’s just very cool from a fan’s perspective to see landmarks that look as if they were ripped straight from the page, such as a ruined Atlanta City and Hershel’s farm. Even more exciting still is the liberties that the show is taking with it’s storyline. Important plot points from the show such as Jenner and the CDC, and Sophia going missing were completely absent from the comic.
However, the most drastic departure from the comic is the presence of Shane. In the comic book, Shane was killed at the end of the very first storyline at the hands of seven year old Carl, yet here he is still alive and (sort of) well on the show, serving as the resident anti-hero type character. Sitting somewhere between deplorable and sympathetic, Shane is by far the most interesting and three-dimensional character on the show. There are many different aspects of the character that were barely touched upon within the first six issues of the comic; his brotherly affection and rivalry with Rick, the clear devotion he has to Carl, and the dangling love triangle between Rock, Shane, and Rick’s wife Lori.
All of this is very emotional stuff, and for fans of the comics, it makes the show infinitely more interesting. I’ve always thought the Harry Potter movies would do better if they did not try to stick so close to the original storyline, and I feel like The Walking Dead is proof of that. Rather than just retelling what readers of the comic already know, the show gives us a new take on a familiar world, a fun companion to an already great storyline that is in some ways superior to the original.
To be honest, I feel like much of the show’s success has little to do with it’s status as a live action comic book show; in fact, quite the opposite.
I think the show’s success is correalated to the series mainstream zombie appeal, as many people I have spoken to that were unaware that a comic book even existed.
This would be rather fitting; after all, most people are not even aware that the popular horror show
Tales From the Crypt was based off of a
horror comic of the same name from the 1950’s.
Still, recognized in it’s status or not, if you’re a fan of good television, you owe it to yourself to check this show out.
So far, I have not seen one person regret it.